The Controversy Behind the Change

In the shaded groves and sunlit meadows where birders gather, a spirited debate has taken wing (punny, I know). The AOS’s proposal to change eponymous bird names has stirred a nest of diverse opinions, echoing through the forests and across the birding blogs. 

The Case for Change

Advocates for the renaming see it as a necessary step towards a more inclusive and descriptive birding culture. They argue that many of the names we use today are relics of a colonial past, honoring individuals whose actions or beliefs may no longer align with contemporary values. Proponents believe that renaming these birds offers a chance to rectify historical oversights and create a more welcoming environment for all bird enthusiasts.

The Thick-billed Longspur, a bird species native to North America, was formerly known as the “McCown’s Longspur.” The original name honored John Porter McCown, a Confederate general during the American Civil War. McCown was also an amateur ornithologist, which led to the naming of the bird species after him in the 19th century. However, his association with the Confederacy and its defense of slavery led to calls for a reevaluation of this honor.

In 2020, the AOS decided to change the name from “McCown’s Longspur” to “Thick-billed Longspur.” This decision was part of a broader effort to remove names that are seen as glorifying or memorializing contentious historical figures from the names of bird species. The new name, “Thick-billed Longspur,” describes a prominent physical feature of the bird, its thick bill, which is a common practice in naming species.

Voices of Opposition

On the other side of the spectrum, some birders view this proposal as an overreaction. They argue that the names of birds like Anna’s Hummingbird or Cooper’s Hawk have transcended their original associations and are now simply terms of identification and familiarity, devoid of any historical baggage. For these individuals, the proposal seems to address a concern that is not widely shared, potentially disrupting a well-established naming convention for a perceived fringe issue.

Balancing Tradition and Progress

This debate is not just about names; it’s about how we, as a community, balance respect for tradition with the need for progress. It’s a reflection of a broader societal conversation about history, legacy, and inclusivity. The birding community, known for its passion and knowledge, finds itself at a crossroads, navigating the delicate balance between honoring the past and embracing a more inclusive future.